The Voice and Idol fightin’ over Carrie claims insiders at The Voice and American Idol want Carrie Underwood as a judge. A source tells the site; “The Voice is not taking the return of American Idol lightly and wants to lock down some big names to be exclusive to their show — one name that The Voice wants as a future coach is Carrie Underwood. The problem is that American Idol wants her as well. So she is in the driver’s seat and can really choose her destiny when it comes to doing one of the shows or not. Let the bidding war begin.”